I read Malcolm Gladwell’s Outliers on a plane. I love the guy, and I bought wholesale everything in his last two books. Unfortunately, I know a little too much about the Beatles. The simple thesis of the book is: success is based on environmental factors, i.e., luck. One of his examples is that the Beatles’ success is predicated on their having played 8 hours a night, five nights a week in Hamburg. They got the 10,000 hours he deems necessary for expertise, and hence their artistic preeminence.
But the primary factor in that preeminence is songwriting–which they didn’t do in Hamburg. And the covers they played all night, when they ended up on Beatles albums, sound pretty stiff–“Roll Over Beethoven,” for instance. The best thing a million gigs can do for a band is tighten up the rhythm section–and most of their time in Hamburg, they played without Ringo (and anybody who fronts on Ringo, the fattest, heftiest rock drummer that ever was, is a sucker)–they played with Pete Best, who got fired. The secret weapon in the Beatles is Paul McCartney’s bass playing (I got a bootleg of some solo-ed Paul bass lines, and the sound, the style, and his rhythmic acumen is astonishing)–and he didn’t play bass in Hamburg–Stu Sutcliffe, who died before they started recording, did.
Maybe the one solid element strengthened would be the harmonies–which I couldn’t imagine the Beatles without.
So now I’m questioning all those dramatic empirical examples that I ate up in the last books–maybe I should’ve been more skeptical.
I kicked some people out of a gig in Woodstock. What a dreadful drag.
Scrap and I were playing the Bearsville Theater, which is an amazing place to play. There was a guy near the front yelling back and forth with his friend. So I stopped, ha ha ha, hey man, please keep it down. Next song, he keeps talking. I stop, give him a less comic chiding. Next song, he keeps talking. I stopped mid-chorus, and had him kicked out.
It divided the audience. A woman was yelling at me “He’s your fan! He’s your fan!” I felt bad. In retrospect, I wish I’d been nicer about it–I still would’ve kicked him out, though.
I’m not inclined to be sympathetic to those guys just because they liked the music. They were talking loudly, and nobody else in the crowd was. My point of view is that they were ruining the show for people that wanted to watch the show, rather than talk through it. I gave ‘em a couple of warnings, and then when they couldn’t pipe down, I kicked ‘em out.
Obviously, when I’m playing to a loud drunk crowd it’s less fun for me. I’ll make jokes to try and shut the crowd up, but if that’s the deal, I just put my head down and get through the set–though I think it’d be a more fun show to watch when the artist is actually into it, not just trying to get to the end. Still, if that’s the deal, that’s the deal. But, when it’s four drunks that are the only ones talking, messing with everybody else’s experience, it’s what I have to do.
I’ve kicked more people out of shows in the last couple of years than I’ve done previously. I had a woman in Williamsburg, VA booted because she was babbling at the top of her lungs–I think, directly to me–when everybody else in the theater was being quiet. At a Brooklyn gig, I booted a group of drunk guys leaping up and down and whacking everybody else in the face in their enthusiasm.
Being a Silence Nazi is a drag. Bad vibe in the show, too. But I don’t know what else to do.
After the gig, when we were loading the instruments in the car, the drunks I kicked out were waiting for me. They were pleading, saying how much they loved the music, and that they were the greatest fans, etc. I thanked them, really, sincerely, for listening. But that’s really immaterial. You have to think about the people you’re watching the show with.
(They also claimed that I didn’t warn them–evidence of their drunkenness, and reinforcement for my ex post facto belief that I should’ve been kinder, even as I had them booted)
There was another woman at the show, likely drunk, who approached the stage and just started talking at me–oblivious to the fact that the show was going on. Or, maybe, thinking that she was entitled to take it over. I brushed her off, she persisted, I yelled at her to sit down. After the gig, she was waiting in the line where I was selling CDs, and as soon as she came up, I said, Uh-uh, no way, not talking to you, get out of here.
“Why are you so angry?” she kept saying. Just with you, I said. Still, it got to me.
There were lots of people in line that thanked me for kicking the inconsiderate jerks out, but I got two angry emails this morning–not from people that I kicked out, but people that thought I was a dick in doing so.
I heard Glen Campbell’s version of the Foo Fighters’ “Times Like These” on Joe Belock’s WFMU show. It sounded so assured, so classic, that I immediately assumed that the Foos had covered Glen’s tune, not the other way around, and I had just never been aware of it. (“Times Like These,” in fact, had gone in one ear and out the other when I’ve heard it previously, but, like a great cover version should do, I realized what a great tune it was)
The album, Meet Glenn Campbell, has apparently been out for a while, and has a Green Day cover and a Paul Westerberg cover, and a couple Tom Petty tunes–it would sound cringeworthy to me, had I not actually heard the record, which is fantastic. Big string arrangements, and the guy’s voice is just fantastic.
But I guess it hasn’t made much noise. (Unless it’s playing on country radio? I don’t know) I wonder if these kind of records will get made much anymore–huge-sounding, expensive-sounding records by an artist without a recent string of hits.